Gas vs Electric Stove: Which Is Better for Your Kitchen (And Maintenance Costs)

When buying or upgrading a stove, most homeowners face one big question: gas or electric?
Both have strong advantages depending on your cooking style, home setup, and energy costs. But beyond cooking performance, there’s another factor often overlooked   maintenance and repair costs. Let’s compare both sides clearly so you can make the right choice.

Performance and Cooking Experience
Gas stoves deliver instant heat and fine temperature control, making them ideal for professional or frequent home cooks.
Electric stoves, on the other hand, heat more evenly on flat surfaces and are easier to clean. If you bake often, electric models maintain consistent oven temperatures better than gas.

Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs
Gas models heat faster but lose energy through open flames. Electric stoves convert nearly all supplied energy into heat but take longer to reach temperature.

Your location also matters in Ontario, electricity rates tend to be higher than natural gas, so long-term operating costs for gas stoves can be lower.

Installation Requirements
Gas stoves require a gas line connection and proper ventilation. If your kitchen doesn’t have an existing line, installation costs may rise significantly.

Electric stoves only need a compatible 240-volt outlet, making them easier and cheaper to install in most homes.

Maintenance and Repair Considerations
Gas stoves typically need more frequent maintenance burners and igniters can clog or fail over time. However, repairs are usually simple and inexpensive.

Electric stoves have fewer moving parts but can be costly when major components like heating elements or control boards fail.
As a rule of thumb:

• Gas repairs: More frequent, lower cost per visit.
• Electric repairs: Less frequent, higher cost per repair.

Safety and Ventilation
Gas leaks, carbon monoxide buildup, and open flames are the main safety concerns with gas appliances.
Electric stoves eliminate these risks, though their surfaces remain hot long after use. For families with small children, electric cooktops are often safer overall.

Longevity and Replacement Costs
Both types can last 10–15 years, depending on usage. Gas stoves often outlast electric ones because their mechanical systems are simpler.
However, electric induction models, while more expensive upfront, offer better efficiency and modern features that extend their service life.

Which Should You Choose?
Choose Gas if you want faster heat response, lower long-term operating costs, and you already have a gas line.
Choose Electric if you value simple installation, easier cleaning, and safer operation.
Ultimately, your best option depends on both your cooking habits and the infrastructure in your home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is a gas stove cheaper to run than electric in Ontario?
A: Usually yes. Natural gas is generally less expensive per unit of energy compared to electricity, though rates can vary by season and supplier.

Q: Which stove type lasts longer?
A: Gas stoves tend to have longer lifespans due to simpler components, while electric and induction models may need part replacements over time.

Q: Are electric stoves safer than gas?
A: Yes. Electric models eliminate open flames and reduce carbon monoxide risk, though surfaces remain hot for several minutes after use.

Aidan Appliance Repair and Installation offers expert stove installation and repair services for both gas and electric models across Guelph and nearby areas.
131 Raymond St, Guelph, ON | 1 (289) 208-3700